Showing posts with label sustainability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sustainability. Show all posts

Sunday, March 27, 2011

On Materials Science and Engineering in Energy

Solar tower concentrates light reflected from surrounding panels.  (Source: Paul Langrock/Zenit/Laif/Redux)
A thoroughly interesting report [1] has recently been published regarding the future of materials science and engineering in energy and related fields.  The report is available on-line here; and it is also summarized in the latest issue of the Journal of Minerals, Metals, and Materials (JOM) [2].  The report is written well and with the general public in mind; for the hobby scientist, it also helps convey a thought-provoking state-of-the-art in materials science and engineering.  To summarize the already-summarized article in JOM, the topics in the report - and subjects which will be in the forefront of future materials study - are:

Functional Surface Technology (or: making the surfaces of materials perform in new/different/improved ways).  This includes:
  • Catalysts with high selectivity and conversion efficiency.  When catalysts aren't efficient, energy is wasted.
  • Smart coating / lubricant systems for lightweight alloys.  Lighter alloys such as aluminum and magnesium tend to wear down relatively quickly. 
  • Coatings to inhibit galvanic corrosion.  Corroded materials' performance rapidly degrades.
  • Solar photovoltaic materials utilizing a broader spectrum of light.  Current solar panels only collect a fraction of the light energy available.
  • Treatment processes to rebuild or enhance surfaces.  Materials' recycle-ability, re-use, and service life can all extended.
  • High flux membranes for selective separation of atmospheric gases.  Capture of carbon dioxide emissions, for example, can be made more efficient and scalable to industrial levels.    

Higher-Performance Materials for Extreme Environments.  This includes:
  • High-temperature, phase-stable alloys.  Long-term properties degrade in industrial systems which operate using high-temperature and chemically-aggressive conditions.
  • Thermoelectric materials with high conversion efficiency.  Thermoelectric materials convert waste heat into electricity, and can help recapture lost energy.
  • Lightweight, high-strength ductile materials.  Trade-offs typically exist: strength at the expense of ductility; light weight at the expense of strength; and so on.
  • Irradiation-resistant structural alloys for nuclear applications.  Nuclear irradiation degrades the mechanical properties of many materials. 
  • High-pressure hydrogen-resistant materials.  Storage and handling of hydrogen is not an easy task.
  • Collaborative, comprehensive materials database.  Materials development can be sped and cost reduced.
  • Predictive materials performance code.  Computer modeling of materials' mechanical properties will enable rapid, inexpensive, and iterative development.

Multi-Materials Integration in Energy Systems (or: composites to provide what the individual components can't).  This includes:
  • Low-cost carbon fibers and composites manufacturing processes.  Carbon fiber products are too expensive to manufacture for widespread use.
  • Joining process for assembling multi-material structures. Some material pairs are incompatible (i.e. structurally or chemically) and can not form suitable joints or be brought into contact.
  • High energy density, low-cost battery cathodes.  Improved battery longevity, storage, and discharge will enable new alternative energy technologies.
  • Low-cost fuel cell catalyst.  A current benchmark catalyst, Platinum, rare and expensive, is not ideal.
  • Integrated computational materials engineering modeling package.  Initial composite design and proof-of-concept can be performed first through computation, saving development time and costs.

Sustainable Manufacturing of Materials.  This includes:
  • Net-shape processing of structural metals.  Scrap and waste (e.g. from machining a block of steel into its final shape) can be reduced.
  • Additive manufacturing of components and systems.  Energy-intensive production methods and industrial systems as a whole can be made more efficient.
  • Low-cost processing and energy reduction technology for metals.  Lightweight metals such as aluminum, titanium, and magnesium can benefit greatly from improved processing methods.
  • Separation of materials for recycling.  Major efficiency barriers surround the screening and sorting of mixed materials.  Carbon fiber recycling is also expensive.
  • Real-time sensor technology for gases and molten metals.  Enhanced detection methods are needed for identifying damage during processing of high-performance and energy-intensive products. 

This report covers a lot of ground regarding sustainability of materials science and engineering in energy and related fields.  But it also presents a good overview of the diversity and breadth of the meaning or interpretation of sustainability - an important point that should be considered alongside the sustainability design itself.  

[1] Linking Transformational Materials and Processing for an Energy-Efficient and Low-Carbon Economy: Creating the Vision and Accelerating Realization - Opportunity Analysis for Materials Science and Engineering.  The Mining, Metals, and Materials Society (2011).  (Available On-Line.)
[2] L. Robinson.  Opportunity analysis for MSE - Report defines pathway to a more sustainable energy future.  JOM, Vol. 63 (Issue 2) (2011), pp. 30-33.

Saturday, February 5, 2011

On Sustainable Materials Innovation

A recent article written by James Moody over at SEED Magazine [1] describes a new approach to getting around Intellectual Property (IP) roadblocks experienced in developing countries.  For example, in areas where food is in short supply, where it is insecure, or in areas where malnutrition is frequent, there are technologies which may solve these problems.  However [1]:

"Many key technologies are covered by patents, because the people and companies that have invested in research and development have a reasonable expectation for profits.  Companies have been making valuable patents available for humanitarian uses for years, but quite often it has been an ad hoc effort requiring intensive legal work and expense for both [Non-Governmental Organization] NGOs and corporations."

Companies require a sufficient market potential / size in order to justify spending the time, energy, and resources necessary to develop a product - be it food, drug, material, or otherwise.  In addition, the research and development of a new product can be slowed significantly navigating through the existing IP space and avoiding infringement.  Moody's proposed solution is a Global Responsibility License (GRL) - a modular or temporary release of patent information by a patent holder to a public or not-for-profit organization.  Such a license would allow the utility of patent information for 'non-market' uses, specifically for humanitarian and development purposes; the patent holder, meanwhile, retains the economic value of the patent while further developing a new market opportunity for it.

But is this the whole story?  And do the problems outlined by Moody translate to the materials industry and its innovations?  In order to answer these questions, I'll draw from previously published works on these subjects.

Conflict, Innovation, and IP

As described by Eisenberg and Nelson [2], fundamental innovation conflict arises when trying to divide between basic science and applied technology, or, alternatively, the public and private domains. "The challenge for public policy is to devise arrangements that preserve the great advantages of an open system for basic science while still preserving profit incentives for the creation of valuable new products."  Additional conflict arises when access to even basic science becomes restricted, such as through [2-4]: ownership of research results, inefficient patent pricing, broad patent scoping, or exclusivity licensing.  On the other hand, Nelson has argued that problems of 1) assembling permissions or licenses prior to performing work, and 2) access limitation by patent holders to research having high practical promise, are not significant and of limited evidence [3].

It has been said [2] that businesses, "driven by the hope of profit and the fear of competition, have a far better feel than government agencies for the kinds of new products the market wants and can respond more quickly to emerging demand and technological opportunities."  One example given is the development of medication for AIDS patients in sub-Saharan Africa.  In this case, government subsidized the access to these inventions made by private research and development groups [2].  Similarly, the One Laptop Per Child program was in part funded by the United Nations.  On the other hand is the drive of the scientific community to contribute significant research to the scientific commons.  As outlined in [2], public funding was instrumental in the Human Genome Project; it helped generate research results in the public domain, thereby making the human genome sequence freely available.

Aside from the examples provided above, there have been proposals to further improve the efficiency of general research and its navigation through IP space.  Nelson [3] describes the incorporation of a "kind of research exemption, analogous to the fair use exemptions in copyright law, into patent law."  However, the Bayh-Dole Act encourages Universities to claim IP rights to data or technology developed during publicly-funded research; this leaves industry less willing to provide such research exemptions [2,3].  A solution may be met if the exempted research was agreed not to be patented; but Nelson believes this kind of exemption may still require a trip through Congress.  As this appears to be the kind of solution proposed by Moody [1] - but for humanitarian instead of research purposes - some work would be required to clearly define the divide between the two.      

Application to Materials Industries

The method and pathway to innovation varies significantly from field to field [4,5]. In other words, while the solution proposed by Moody may apply to some industries, new materials and their innovation do not necessarily require the same pathway or experience the same difficulties.

While considered the "source of revolutionary technologies," Maine et al [6] argue that there are two key barriers to management of new materials: 1) the long gestation period between material discovery and market introduction, and 2) the large cumulative investment necessary to commercialize them.  Of the former, I previously noted that a time period of 15 years can be required; Maine [7] lists examples of new materials innovations which have gestation periods of 20 years or more.  These mismatches and delays can be due to a number of reasons, such as separation between material and end user, unsuitable research & development (R&D) corporate strategies, or flawed R&D valuation methodologies [6].  Because of the significant costs and risks involved, therefore, IP and its ownership is critical to extract value from materials innovations; it is also critical to sustainably guide future material developments [6,7].  Maine et al [6] have recently developed an Investment Methodology for Materials (IMM) in order to help focus industry 1) on materials development and investment and 2) reduce this gestation time.  Critical in the IMM is Value Capture, the IMM component that pays particular attention to the material appropriability, i.e. the measure of degree of IP protection.

IP space traversal in the materials industry is also unique.  For example, technical alliances and collaborations are frequently undertaken between companies; collaborations preferred are generally of the small, simple, flexible, temporary, and collective type [8], somewhat analogous to Moody's proposal.  Through collaboration, a number of benefits can be realized [8], most notably the increase in innovation speed and avoidance of roadblocks by existing patents.  In fact, Niosi [8] notes that Canadian advanced materials companies could easily "invent around" existing patents, or they would simply label the results as trade secrets.  In cases where IP was generated, the main problem was found to be its division between partners, which could be defined at the outset [8].

Sustainable Materials Innovation

The materials industry, despite being a unique field, may still encounter the difficulties outlined by Moody n future innovation.  In particular, ownership of research results, inefficient patent pricing, broad patent scoping, or exclusivity licensing may increasingly exclude users from performing research or otherwise socially valuable activities [2,3].  While ownership of research results may be bypassed with non-patent agreements; while costs may be relieved by the allocation of public funds in cases where private firms have little financial incentive; while patent scoping may be narrowed through the patent office and courts; and while license acquisition can be resolved by patent holders making information widely available and on reasonable terms, considerable work is needed to examine the real economic cost of the current system [3].

Epilogue: Sustainable Materials Innovation in Canada

Canadian manufactured goods focus more on the use of traditional rather than advanced materials [8].  As a result, in Canada there is generally a small market for advanced materials development, and weakness of their production and use in the private sector [see 8].  Sustainable materials innovation in Canada may then possess a cautious optimism.  Due to the sheer volume of these native, traditional materials, sustainable materials innovation in Canada is well-suited to focus on their appropriation.  On the other hand, by focusing too narrowly on such traditional materials, Canada risks the danger of falling behind others in emerging materials markets and industries, missing out on new high-technology industries, and slowly diminishing its market share.

[1] J. Moody.  On re-thinking IP.  SEED Magazine, January 31, 2011.  (Available On-Line.)
[2] R.S. Eisenberg, R.R. Nelson.  Public vs. proprietary science: a fruitful tension?  Academic Medicine, Vol. 77 (2002) pp. 1392-1399. (Available On-Line.)
[3] R.R. Nelson.  The market economy, and the scientific commons.  Research Policy, Vol. 33 (2004) pp. 455-471.  (Available On-Line.)
[4] R.P. Merges, R.R. Nelson.  On the complex economics of patent scope.  Columbia Law Review, Vol. 90 (1990), pp. 839-916.  (Text Available On-Line.)
[5] S.G. Winter.  Patents in complex contexts: incentives and effectiveness.  In: Owning Scientific and Technical Information (1998) pp. 41-60.
[6] E. Maine, D. Probert, M. Ashby.  Investing in new materials: a tool for technology managers.  Technovation, Vol. 25 (2005) pp. 15-23.
[7] E. Maine.  Innovation and Adoption of New Materials.  Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cambridge (2000).
[8] J. Niosi.  Strategic partnerships in Canadian advanced materials.  R&D Management, Vol. 23 (1993) pp. 17-27.

Saturday, January 22, 2011

Sustainable Re-Construction in Small Closed Systems

Rubble in streets of Haiti (image from Gerald Herbert/Associated Press - source).

A year after Haiti's devastating earthquake, re-construction efforts there have come upon significant hurdles.  In the latest issue of the American Ceramic Society Bulletin is a great article detailing these hurdles [1] (info also over at ScienceDaily).  According to the article authors DesRoches et al:

"The unprecedented damage was caused by, to a large extent, the absence of seismic details, poor-quality materials (concrete and steel) and lack of quality control in construction."

And more, it is the debris itself which is limiting progress:

"...we believe that landfilling this volume of debris is impossible.  And, our calculations show typical disposal techniques are simply not practical.  The debris has created a huge logjam that is blocking re-construction.  Land can't be cleared, streets can't be opened and even foot traffic must be re-routed over long distances.  Nevertheless, the concrete and other debris largely remain where it was when the earthquake struck ... we estimate that debris removal could take 20 years or longer to accomplish at current removal rates."

Sustainability has different meanings in different areas of the world.  Improved materials, extended means for waste removal / treatment, and higher quality control are possible in more affluent, large, or capable areas.  Haiti, on the other hand, in the state as described by DesRoches et al, may be better thought of as a small closed system, e.g., such as Easter Island [2].  Sustainable re-construction in a small closed system means:
  • Given the inability to ship rubble elsewhere, new construction materials must incorporate a maximum amount of rubble; 
  • Given the need to re-use rubble in new construction, the construction materials must possess maximum recycle-ability; and
  • Incorporation or utility of complex / process-intensive / energy-intensive materials during re-construction can be minimal.
On its face, the latter point is particularly important for Haiti, given the difficulty of maintaining high levels of quality control.  However, the latter point also reflects the more subtle but important links between thermodynamics and sustainability in small closed systems.  More specifically, that the energy and entropy in a system must be closely in tune with the physical limitations of that system; and that is no more true than when evaluating or designing materials for small closed systems. 

[1] R.R. DesRoches, K.E. Kurtis, and J.J. Gresham.  Breaking the reconstruction logjam: Haiti urged to recycle concrete rubble.  Bulletin of the American Ceramic Society, Vol. 90 (2011), pp. 20-26.
[2] P. Nagarajan.  Collapse of Easter Island: Lessons for sustainability of small islands.  Journal of Developing Societies, Vol. 22 (2006), pp. 287-301.